Is Bath Fitter Any Good?

Aug 16, 2024 Yankee Home

When considering a bathroom remodel, one of the popular names that often comes up is Bath Fitter.

Known for its fast installation and convenience, Bath Fitter has made a name for itself in the bathroom remodeling industry.

But is Bath Fitter really as good as it seems?

The Convenience Factor

One of the primary selling points of Bath Fitter is its convenience.

The process involves installing a new acrylic liner over your existing tub or shower, often completed in just one day.

This can be a significant advantage for those looking to avoid the mess and disruption of a traditional renovation.

Pictured here is a dumpster filled with liners, tubs and showers that have been removed from homes.

The Reality Check

While the convenience of Bath Fitter is undeniable, it’s important to consider the full picture.

Surface-Level Solution

Bath Fitter’s approach focuses on covering up the existing structure rather than addressing underlying issues.

This means problems like mold, mildew, or water damage can persist unnoticed beneath the new liner.

Potential for Long-Term Issues

Over time, the acrylic liner may shift or develop gaps, leading to water seepage and potential damage to the substructure.

This can result in costly repairs down the line.

Limited Customization

With Bath Fitter, your options for customizing the design, color, and features of your tub or shower are limited.

This might not satisfy homeowners looking for a truly personalized bathroom remodel.

Pictured here are the pieces of a tub and shower enclosure that was removed from a home in Springfield, MA. The image includes the original tile with adhesive where Bath Fitter’s liner walls were attached.

Cost & Value

The cost of a Bath Fitter installation typically ranges from $3,000 to $12,000.

While this might be attractive for a quick makeover, it does not provide a long-lasting solution.

Homeowners might end up spending more money in the long run on repairs and additional renovations due to unresolved underlying issues.

You may be wondering what costs are attributed to a walk-in shower or shower remodel.

Click here to read more about How Much A Walk-In Shower Costs.

A Better Alternative

Thorough and Detailed

There are companies besides Bath Fitter that offer a long term solution for your tub or shower project.

Instead of opting for a liner that goes over your existing space, there are specialized craftsmen that demo down to the studs, allowing an opportunity to identify and fix any problems like leaks or structural damage.

This ensures a solid foundation for your new bathroom features.

This picture features a shower project that has everything removed down to the studs ensuring a blank slate is the starting point for a new tub or shower.

High-Quality Materials

There are contractors that use premium materials designed for durability and long-lasting performance, rather than a thin plastic liner.

Your new tub or shower will not only look beautiful but also withstand daily use for years to come when opting for a contractor that uses higher quality materials.

Endless Customization

With other bath contractors, you have the freedom to choose from a wide range of designs, colors, and features, and even an option to change the layout of your space!

Bath Fitter is limited to how much you can customize a space due to the fact that no demolition occurs during their process.

Whether you prefer a sleek modern look or a classic style, you should be able to create a bathroom that reflects your personal taste.

Long-Term Value

Although the initial cost of a full gut of a bath or shower is higher than a Bath Fitter project, it is a worthwhile investment for a long term solution.

By addressing all underlying issues and using high-quality materials, your home could benefit from a durable and permanent solution that adds significant value to your home.